Oh God… I know I’m getting flak for this one…
Mary Poppins. What the hell is this movie such a beloved Children’s classic? IMDB rates it with a 7.7 out of 10. Rotten Tomatoes gives it 100%!?!?!?
Ugh…
Okay, so here’s the deal, there are very few Disney movies that I’m willing to speak negatively about. Even some of the worse ones like Pocahantas or Song of the South, are movies I will watch and watch again. Despite the incredible $$ to buy it legally, Song of the South is an excellent film.
But Mary Poppins is one of those few. Why? Because it’s depressing! The movie really seems to be a series of mini-adventures that the characters go through. From the laughing uncle, to Bert’s street drawings, to the father’s transformation. There is certainly nothing wrong with that, in fact it gives the movie an almost epic feel… however, have you noticed that most of the mini-adventures end on a downer? I’m not kidding, the movie is depressing. The drawings Bert worked hard on get washed away, the father has no time/tolerance for his children, the mother is too busy being an activist (hippie), the servants are mean to each other… and what the hell is up with the guys on top of the building pretending to be on a ship?
This is one thing that has always bugged me, did this guy fight in World War 2 and take a blow to the head or something? I mean he seems to be a sort of minor nuisance throughout the movie until the scene with the Chimney Sweeps. At this point… for some unknown reason the Captain get’s paranoid at all the dancing sweeps and… FIRES A CANNON AT THEM!?!? WTF!? Someone let this guy have a cannon… in a country where the police aren’t even allowed to carry guns… really!? How is he not getting arrested? How has he not been committed???
That’s my other problem with the movie… very very little is explained. There is little to no back story, no character development, no exposition, nothing! What the hell is Mary Poppins? Is she a witch, some kind of angel, or something else? How does Bert know Mary? What made their father such a jerk? Where does Mary get her powers? Why does the letter get to Mary? What causes the old man at the end and the laughing guy to float on the ceiling? WHO THE HELL GAVE THE MENTALLY DISTURBED NEIGHBORHOOD CAPTAIN A #@%$ING CANNON!?!?
Then we get down to the worst possible part of this movie… Feed the Birds… uh… you know what? I don’t even want to talk about this. It’s sad, wicked sad. In a movie that seems to be ridden with downers, this one scene is like the embodiment of everything that is wrong with the movie. That’s all I’m going to say about it for the sake of sanity.
Moving on… (mercifully)
There are days when I really don’t like giving a movie a bad review. I am well aware of how beloved this movie is. Julie Andrews gives a powerhouse performance and her singing is at it’s peak. Supporting cast members Dick Van Dyke, and the legendary David Tomlinson (one of my childhood favorites), are also quite good. But in the end, if the story isn’t good… all the great acting and musical numbers in the world can’t save it.
For all the positives, and as much as I hate to say it, this is a bad movie. A total lack of character development and back story is bad enough. But then the primary story is just one run of depression or another. Yes the animated scene is quite enjoyable, but even that ends on a downer. Shockingly enough, even with all the misery this movie delivers, it somehow still manages to end on a high note.
I honestly would have preferred it if it ended on a downer. I mean Old Yeller was a depressing Disney movie that scarred many children, but at least it went all the way with what it was doing. So look, I know I’m in the minority on this one, but Mary Poppins is definitely near the bottom of the barrel of Disney movies for me. It’s depressing, it’s an emotional cluster eff, and you wind up leaving with so many unanswered questions.